This is the first installment of what will probably be a long string of articles on the inconsistencies that have plagued the official statements of the Anthony family. I have chosen to name it the Anthony Encycliepedia…because it basically will constitute a compendium of…lies! I will be creating a new page in the Library that will contain links to all Encycliepedia entries, for research. There will be an entry for each “topic of lie-age”…so to speak. I will only pull from the interviews and depositions. But I look forward to the Hinky readers contributing in the comments with conflicting statements on a given topic that they find in media interviews.
The first topic I have chosen is about George’s account of when he arrived home on July 15th, the night the 911 calls were made and all hell broke loose. Now, you may think, what’s so important about George’s account of coming home? Very good question! The importance of this first topic is to show HOW the Anthonys (in this particular case I’m talking about Cindy and George) “operate”. There has been a long standing opinion that Cindy controls what George says. While I can’t really argue the validity of that statement, I can offer the following to show that George also is very adept at influencing Cindy. They have achieved liar-symbiosis…again, so to speak. And we will see this two-way “effect” in future topics addressed in the Encycliepedia.
So let’s look at what George has to say about arriving at the Anthony home on July 15, 2008.
In George’s July 24, 2008 interview with OCSO, beginning on page 19, George tells of arriving home that night.
I got home at ten minutes to ten. That’s when my wife was standing outside, walking, pacing back and forth in the driveway. The car’s still inside the garage. And my wife fell apart. She said, “George, we lost her. We lost her.” And I said, “Lost who? Lost who?” She said, “Caylee, Caylee.” And I said, “What’s going on?” I didn’t, I didn’t even know at that time that my daughter was even home.”
George elaborates more on the dramatic scene that occurred in the driveway of the Anthony home in his August 5, 2009 deposition with the state, beginning on page 245:
I pull directly behind Cindy’s car and I see Cindy out outside of our garage pacing back and forth. Step out of my car: Hey, what’s going on?
And that’s when she told me that Caylee was missing; Caylee had been taken. And she said someone by the name of Zanny had her and Casey was inside with Lee.
Q Did at that moment, did the smell of the car come into your thought process?
A No. It didn’t. It didn’t. All I wanted to do is hold onto Cindy. I’m holding onto her. She’s falling apart in my arms. And I wanted to go in and see Casey. It wasn’t probably five minutes, I don’t know how many Orange County Sheriff’s Department people — I’m getting ahead of myself for a second.Before me going into the house, I asked Cindy if she called the sheriff’s department, if she made a report. And that’s when she told me she had made three different reports, one to the Orlando Police Department, I think two to Orange County, and — and they should be arriving any time. And I told her: That’s not good enough. We’re calling them again.
And it wasn’t maybe five minutes, something like that, next thing I know is I think we had maybe three, four, maybe five sheriff’s deputy cars out in front of our house.
Q Did you go in and try to talk to Casey?
A I tried to. But like I said, everything happened so quickly. The sheriff’s department is there. I maybe had maybe ten minutes with my daughter, if that, that night.
Okay, so when we look at these two accounts of George arriving home on the night of the 15th, we see that the three 911 calls have been made, George thinks they should call again, but within 5 minutes (which was more than ample time to make another 911 call) the police arrive.
But there is a problem here. We have the audio of the third 911 call made by Cindy. In this last 911 call we clearly hear that George has walked into the home while Cindy is on the phone and Cindy begins to hysterically yell information to George on what has transpired. There was no driveway incident, there was no pacing Cindy, and there was no “we’ve lost her” out in the Florida twilight. Further to that, George had to have known that Casey was there (contrary to his July 24th statements…which are also contrary to his August 5, 2009 statements, which makes it a contrary of a contrary which may actually either make something true, or create a wormhole in the driveway of the Anthony home) because in this same exchange is when Cindy tells Casey that the operator wants to speak to her and Casey attempts to refuse to speak to the operator….right there, in front of George.
George also sticks with this same story in his answers during the civil deposition on April 4, 2009, beginning on page 52:
Q were you present, by the way, during any of the 911 calls that your wife –
A No.
Q — made?
A No, I was not.
Okay, so George is firmly sticking with all three 911 calls have been made by the time he gets home. He’s stating in three separate sworn statements…I wasn’t there during the 911 calls.
Now, on July 29, 2009, Cindy was deposed by the state. In this deposition Cindy tells of the dramatic scene in the driveway.
Q Did George come home between the time you made that last 9-1-1 call?
A I had already made the last 9-1-1 call and then he came home.
Q And then the police arrived; is that the correct order?
A Yeah. I think he had just pulled up, as I remember, going back out. Because I heard a car pull up and it was George’s, and I thought it was the sheriff’s department. And I remember coming out in the driveway, and he goes: What’s going on? And I told him that Caylee was missing. I was in the driveway and I — I kind of almost collapsed in the driveway.
Q What did he do?
A He ran over to me and grabbed me. And he says: What do you mean? And I told him what Casey had said.
So there you have it. Cindy has backed George’s statements up. He was NOT there during any of the 911 calls. He arrived as she frantically paced in the driveway and caught her in her moment of collapsedness…again, so to speak. Anyone who has thought that the male voice they heard in the background of the third 911 call, the person that Cindy was hysterically screaming a “recap” of the evening’s events to was George needs to notice…it could not be George. Not according to George and Cindy. Now, I’m real unclear who would be arriving in the middle of this chaotic scene that Cindy would need to be frantically updating, but apparently – we’re all wet behind the ears thinking it was George.
Or are we?
From Lee’s deposition with the state on July 30, 2009, page 155:
Q Let me stop you for a second.
A Sure.
Q Your dad home at this point?
A Yes. He is home.
Q All right.
A He got home right when my mom was making that second 9-1-1 call. [NOTE: Lee repeatedly refers to the third 911 call as the second because it was the second call made from the Anthony home while he was there.]
But let’s back up a few pages to see what Lee states about the second 911 call made from the Anthony home:
Q Did you hear any of that 9-1-1 call?
A It was in the background because she called in the living room…
hmmm
Somebody’s lying!
Valhall.
Related posts:
- The Anthony Encycliepedia: George and the gas can
- The Anthony Encycliepedia: George and the smell
- The Anthony Encycliepedia: George talks about Imaginanny
- The Anthony Encycliepedia: Cindy lies to John Allen
- The Anthony Encycliepedia: Cindy talks about money
Click here to join the discussion
